Asphalt shingles cost $5,800–$12,200 and last 20–30 years. Metal roofs cost 2–3x more but last 50–60 years with less maintenance and better heat reflection. Metal is vulnerable to denting from hail, while asphalt is easier and cheaper to install. The right choice depends on your budget, climate priorities, and long-term plans. Driftwood Builders Roofing can walk you through both options.
Ready for a new roof? Let’s compare two different popular roofing types – metal and asphalt shingles – to help you decide the direction you’d like to go in. Read over your options before you decide on metal vs. asphalt shingles in our ultimate comparison guide.
How Do Metal Roofs Compare to Asphalt Shingle Roofs?
As you evaluate your roofing material options, know that both metal and asphalt shingles offer great possibilities for many homes and neighborhoods; the looks of both materials can match many different styles of homes and architecture. Everyone will have their own personal taste, so it can come down to aesthetics and budget. But, let’s break it down more.- Durability Metal roofs can last incredibly long. Some 50 to 100 years if they are made from tough materials. Asphalt shingles aren’t quite as long-lasting; 20 years is the norm for this type of roofing material. However, the value an asphalt shingle has can make it a good contender for many homes.
- Style Metal roofs have a variety of looks, from formed sheets to shingle-type aesthetics. There are also a variety of colors. Metal can also have a coating on top of it to make it look like a shingle. Similarly, asphalt shingles come in a variety of styles and colors to match any home and look.
- Energy Efficiency Surprisingly, metal roofs can be energy efficient. They come with their own insulation options and can be reflective with heat and sun. Asphalt shingles can also be energy efficient with their design, property insulation installation, and energy efficiency ratings. New technologies on asphalt shingles make these a good choice to reflect more light.
- Costs A metal roof can cost about double what an asphalt shingle roof costs. This is a tremendous point to consider when choosing a new roof. Often, insurance costs are impacted by the type of roof you have, so it may be worth it to check in with your insurance agent before making the final decision on asphalt vs. metal roofing.
- Weather Impact Both metal and asphalt can stand up to weather influences. Asphalt shingles can often bear hail storms better, allowing absorption from the bombardment of hail. Many metal roofs can dent more easily from this type of weather issue.
- Noise Metal roofs can be pretty noisy during inclement weather like hail or rain storms. If your community gets a lot of weather like this, asphalt shingles can be considerably quieter and absorb or insulate from the noise that storms can create.